The Mennonite Archives of Ontario had its origin in the research undertaken by Lewis J. Burkholder in the early 1930s for his book A Brief History of the Mennonites in Ontario. During his research he gathered a significant quantity of 19th century letters and published documents. He placed these in a "Mennonite box" at the Archives of Ontario in Toronto.
In 1941 an archival collection began to be maintained at the Golden Rule Bookstore (later Provident Bookstore) in Kitchener, Ontario. The manager of the bookstore, J.C. Fretz, was also the historian for the Mennonite Conference of Ontario. At that time the "Mennonite box" was returned to Mennonite hands.
In 1958 an addition to the classroom building at Rockway Mennonite School provided space for archival materials. Additional materials from the Swiss Mennonite community in Ontario began to be gathered under the supervision of Dorothy Schwartzentruber who worked at the bookstore. At some point during those years, the Archives was listed as the “Mennonite Archives of Ontario” (MAO) with the Public Archives of Canada. The Archives has never been incorporated.
The organizational scheme employed by the archives were derived by that developed at the Archives of the Mennonite Church (Goshen, Indiana) by Melvin Gingerich, longtime archivist at that facility. He assisted in the early formation of the Mennonite Archives of Ontario.
In 1963, Conrad Grebel College initiated plans to establish an Ontario Mennonite archives. A committee appointed by the College’s Board of Governors, and including Dorothy Swartzentruber and College President J. Winfield Fretz, recommended that a specific invitation be sent to Grebel’s constituent conferences to deposit their archival materials at the College. Following this, the Board intended to extend the invitation to other Mennonite groups in Ontario to do the same. The Mennonite Historical Society of Ontario was founded in part to assist the Archives with its collection mandate and provide opportunities for archival education.
In 1965, after the construction of the College, the collection was moved from Rockway. The College took charge of the Archives and developed its regional and inter-Mennonite mandate in co-operation with other Mennonite archives in Canada. Lorna Bergey served as volunteer archivist until 1974 at which time Sam Steiner was hired as the first paid staff person. Laureen Harder-Gissing became archivist after Sam's retirement in January 2009.
The Archives has had three locations at Conrad Grebel. The first was on the lower floor of the College's residence. The second was a dedicated space within the library of the Academic building, built in 1976. The third, completed in 2014, tripled archival storage capacity in a state-of-the-art vault, and created new processing and reading rooms within an enlarged library.
The financial resources for the archives are provided by Conrad Grebel University College. Charitable donations to support this program can be made through the Grebel Fund. Donations of planned gifts to the Bowman Endowment for Archives are welcome.