‘Diabolical’ food prices need more than Band-Aid solutions
Check out the full article: ‘Diabolical’ food prices need more than Band-Aid solutions
When talking to a diverse group of youths in Waterloo, I asked them what they thought was one of the biggest challenges that their community experienced. One of them said flatly: “diabolical food prices.” In that moment I realized some problems are not specific to any one community or group — they are universal to all Canadians.
We have all experienced this: sticker shock at grocery stores. When a bag of grapes can cost up to $12, a lot of families have to make difficult choices. Add to that the scourge of “shrinkflation,” and we are getting less and less for every dollar spent. Wages, needless to say, have barely caught up.
What do these difficult choices look like when shopping then? One of them is buying cheaper alternatives — often in the form of ultra-processed foods (UPFs). If you had $4, would you buy a pound of carrots or a five-pack ramen box? One of them will potentially feed a family of three enough so that they don’t go to bed hungry. The math is obvious; the health cost, not so much.
A lot of research has linked UPFs or convenience foods to disastrous health outcomes and, yet, more and more Canadians are gravitating toward them. To be fair, this could be because of a general lack of food literacy or the inability to read and interpret ingredient lists. However, even if governments spent a lot more toward addressing those information gaps, the fact of the matter is that no amount of education can offset the current prohibitive cost of food. While greater awareness and warning labels on packages are welcome initiatives, we need the government to do more to make healthy eating financially accessible in the first place. You can’t lecture someone out of poverty.
I am going to propose a radical idea here. While it would need the refined eye of a policy or food supply chain expert, I will argue it is worth considering. The current status quo is not sustainable, so something has to change.
What if governments added a direct subsidy to fresh produce and unprocessed protein? One way for public policy to work is to incentivize desired behaviour. If we want Canadians to make healthier food choices (or be able to afford three healthy meals a day), we need to remove the barriers that are preventing them from doing so.
Another strategy that could work is to make that incentive front and centre: stickers on fresh produce saying that the item you are buying has an added discount as part of “health promotion subsidy” would certainly grab shoppers’ attention.
Conversely, if policy can reward desired behaviour, it can also disincentivize harmful consumption (or even harmful manufacturing for that matter). The counterpart to a health promotion subsidy could be a “disease prevention tax” – an added percentage tax to any UPF item. The sugar tax has had promising results in many parts of the world; we should genuinely consider it.
A bold label about the added tax on a brightly coloured cereal box would do more to dissuade parents from buying it than any research paper linking food quality to health effects.
The definition of what qualifies as a UPF should be framed by experts (and not funded by the industry with a conflict-of-interest potential). However, if we are putting 16 substances into our bodies in the name of bread, we deserve to have a wider public discourse on it.
We are dealing with two separate but deeply intertwined issues. Statistics Canada (2015) stated that Canadians get 45.7 per cent of their calories from UPFs. Renowned food journalist Michael Pollan argues that most of our supermarket food doesn’t even qualify as food. He calls them “edible foodlike substances,” because of how far they are removed from real food. There is plenty of research linking UPFs to disease. If a significant number of our daily calories in the average Canadian diet is coming from nutrient-deficient, potentially disease-causing “pseudo-foods,” this will eventually put a larger burden on our public-health spending. This certainly seems like an issue worth a policy intervention.
A few caveats need to be mentioned. Simply adding a blanket tax on affordable (but unhealthy) foods, without substantial relief on healthier alternatives, would hurt families even more. Moreover, revenue collected through one tax doesn’t have a clean, direct pathway to be added to a subsidy (but it could still help offset some of the cost in making fresh food affordable for Canadians). Additionally, this strategy alone would not solve the food insecurity crisis. There are many other strategies worth serious consideration too, like discounted city-run subsidized grocery stores, disrupting the monopoly of major supermarket chains, policies to prevent food waste, or teaching communities to grow their own food. Policies need pilot tests to find out the impactful or implementable aspects, but we need to start somewhere. Simply procrastinating on ideas because they seem too radical while reverting to the same status quo is not helping.
Our food banks are overwhelmed by demand. We need more than Band-Aid strategies. We need policy change that will not only help Canadians comfortably put food on the table, but also ensure that food is healthy. It is the government’s responsibility to do both.