Why Ontario is struggling to fight Lake Erie’s toxic green goo

Wednesday, October 10, 2018

view from under water
Ever since 2012, when Canada and the United States signed an agreement pledging to take action on high phosphorus levels in Lake Erie, the two countries have been working to make a dent. Canada’s public and private sectors have shelled out at least $30 million on research and pilot projects aimed at identifying the sources of the phosphorus leaking into the lake and at developing ways to eliminate them — and the toxic algae blooms they produce.

In 2016, the two countries committed to reducing the amount of phosphorus in the lake’s western and central basins by 40 per cent by 2025 (using 2008 levels as a baseline). Ontario has established an interim target of a 20 per cent reduction by 2020. The U.S. has the next seven years, then, to reduce its annual phosphorus loads by 3,316 tonnes. As Canada is responsible for far less phosphorus runoff, its target is far lower, at 212 tonnes.

But this binational effort to save Lake Erie is progressing much more slowly than a previous rescue attempt, mounted after phosphorus levels ballooned in the 1960s and ’70s. Then, a $7.5 billion cleanup effort took only a decade to produce results. Today, scientists are expressing doubts that Canada and the U.S. will be able to meet their targets.

“I’m not saying yes or no; I’m saying I don’t think that the science is there to say definitely that we can,” says Nandita Basu, an engineering and environmental-sciences professor at the University of Waterloo and member of the Water Institute.