Can people with dementia consent to sex?
Philosophy student hopes her research will inform policy for people living with dementia in long-term care homes
Philosophy student hopes her research will inform policy for people living with dementia in long-term care homesBy Claire Prime Faculty of Arts
Photo credit: iStock/Getty Images Plus/serts
By 2030, 75 million people will be diagnosed with dementia worldwide. Many of them will be sexually active. But how can they consent to sex?
It’s a question that Andria Bianchi is examining for her PhD dissertation in philosophy. Through her research, which included placements at two Toronto hospitals as part of the department’s new applied philosophy PhD program, Bianchi learned that many clinicians and caregivers are unsure how to handle the issue of consent for those with dementia, and are uncomfortable talking about it.
"I think it’s a taboo topic," says Bianchi. "It’s something that is not commonly spoken about day to day. Health care workers were more comfortable speaking about medical decisions and sometimes that was the only experience they had and had considered."
Bianchi also learned most institutions don’t have policies about sexual consent and sometimes police are brought in to investigate issues. In 2015, a 78-year-old retiree was found not guilty of sexual abuse after having sex with his wife in an Iowa nursing home. Staff believed she was no longer capable of consenting due to Alzheimer’s disease. Bianchi used the U.S. case to illustrate the challenge in her Three Minute Thesis presentation, for which she was awarded the runner-up prize at the university-level finals on March 23.
The hospital placement experience was eye opening for Bianchi. After months of reviewing literature, Bianchi was surprised to find actual practices in hospitals and nursing homes often differed greatly from recommendations. “A lot of people writing on the topic, including myself, aren’t clinicians and don’t understand the complexities of what they have to deal with every day, including family dynamics. I tend to support what the literature says and going out into the field forced me to contest some of those beliefs.”
While the general topic of decision-making among patients with dementia was well-covered in the literature, Bianchi saw a gap on the topic of sexual decision making. In her placements, nurses and doctors were eager to speak about the broad problems but reticent to speak about sexual consent.
In an effort to enable people with dementia to have their own sex lives, Bianchi envisions three potential approaches to the problem. First, family and clinicians can make decisions based on the patient’s prior wishes and values. Although this might be beneficial in some circumstances, it can be problematic since dementia often changes a person, including their interests, says Bianchi. Sometimes, they forget their spouse.
The second option is, family members and clinicians can try to enable and support a patient, who may struggle to show consent in typical ways, to make their own autonomous decisions. “There are cases where this might not be the best approach, if family members and caregivers have their own values that could be forced onto the person with dementia.”
Finally, consent can be dismissed entirely in this population and family and clinicians can instead focus on individual happiness and pleasure.
Bianchi is uncomfortable with an approach that says people who can’t consent to sex in typical ways shouldn’t be having sex. She hopes her research will inform and influence changes at the institutional or even governmental level. At the very least, she hopes people will talk more about it.
“There’s this descriptive claim that people with dementia are asexual but also this normative claim that, well, they should be asexual,” said Bianchi. “I’m trying to refute that idea and develop ways of enabling them to engage in healthy, informed and autonomous sexual practices.”