a group sitting around a board room table- seen from above
Sociology and Legal Studies Graduate Symposium November 13th, 10:00 A.M. - 5:00 P.M., DWE room 3522
Friday, November 13, 2026 10:00 am - 5:00 pm EST (GMT -05:00)

Graduate Symposium

Presented by the students of Sociology and Legal Studies

We are excited to announce that the first-ever Graduate Symposium in the area of Sociology and Legal Studies is happening on November 13th this Fall term!

What is the Graduate Symposium?

The Graduate Symposium is a forum for current graduate students to showcase their ongoing research. Masters and PhDs in Sociology & Legal studies will be presenting their work, taking questions from the audience, and seeking like-minded researchers from across the University of Waterloo who are as passionate about their research as we are. It is a great opportunity to connect with researchers in your field, get a sense of what Grad school is like, and be a part of a broader intellectual community at the University of Waterloo that bridges undergraduates, graduates, professors, and broader community members alike.

When

Friday, November 13th, from 10:00 AM – 5 PM

Where

DWE Room 3522

Who

Master's and PhD students in Sociology & Legal Studies

What

Conference-style presentations of ongoing research

Why should you attend & what does it entail?

If you are curious about class content, thinking about grad school, or want to meet and chat with future scholars in your areas of interest, this is the perfect avenue to do so. 

There will be multiple sessions over the course of the day from 10:00 AM – 5 PM with varying themes and researchers. You can drop in and out of sessions of interest at your leisure and according to your schedule, graze on snacks and beverages, and say hello to the wonderful graduate students behind all this amazing work, as well as the faculty supervising and mentoring them. 

Who else can attend?

  • Undergraduate students from any faculty
  • Professors from any faculty
  • Family and friends of presenters

Symposium Program


Session 1: Digital Technology & Society

Brooke Sutcliffe, Saf Al-Amry

10:30 A.M. - 11:10 A.M.

1. Casinos Hidden in Video Games: The Harms and Regulation of Lootboxes in a Canadian Context –  Brooke Sutcliffe

This paper explores the infrastructure that facilitates the consumption of loot boxes in video games, the harms caused by them, and how we should conceptualize their regulation. The harms associated with loot boxes are classified using Wood’s (2022) Technology-Harms Relation Framework. Regulation will be discussed through a decentred approach inspired by Black’s (2002) Regulatory Dimensions. This paper argues that no single regulatory dimension is capable of sufficiently curbing harms caused by loot boxes, instead regulation must occur through a decentred blueprint that is both hybrid (combining governmental and non-governmental actors) and multi-faceted (using multiple different strategies across different regulatory dimensions). This paper will address the challenges of defining the harms caused by loot boxes due to the wide range of characteristics that a loot box can have. There is a known correlation between loot box usage and problem gambling; Wood’s framework is applied to argue that it is loot box usage that causes problem gambling, meaning that loot boxes could be a ‘pipeline’ for players to loot box usage to traditional forms of gambling, like sports betting. This is considerably more concerning once the ease of access of loot boxes is taken into account, many games rated “E for Everyone” include these technologies, allowing children to easily fall victim.

2. An Assessment of Smartphone Restriction Policies in Canadian Schools and Their Effects on Children – Saf Al-Amry

Throughout 2024, Canada’s provincial governments each issued new laws restricting smartphone usage in schools (Wong, 2024). This followed mounting agreement among researchers that there are several harms associated with heavy usage of phones, including increased depression and anxiety (Beeres et al., 2021; Fassi et al., 2024; Faelens et al, 2021), limited social skills and increased loneliness (Bonsaksen et al., 2023; Downy & Gibbs, 2020), and a “rewiring” of children’s brains that causes addiction-like symptoms and limited attention spans (Firth et al., 2019; Haidt, 2024). This corroborated teachers’ observations of a decline in grades and achievement paired with reduced attention and motivation during class time, thus leading to support for legal intervention with phone use restriction policies (hereafter PURP) all over Canada’s schools (Nguyen, 2025, Ontario, 2024). The effects of the policies, however, remain empirically untested, having only been around for two years. Thus, my thesis proposal, which I will be presenting at this symposium, aims to understand these policies and test their efficacy, and would do so in three parts. First, I will conduct a content analysis on the state of policies in Canada on the matter of phones in schools. Second, I will use semi-structured interviews with students and teachers to explore the enforcement of PURP in schools and their effects, after two years of enactment. Third, I will use a linear regression to explore changes in achievement over time. To my knowledge, this study will be the first empirical evaluation of the policies’ success or failure, and its results would provide a basis for stakeholders to look at next steps regarding the safeguarding of children and would provide an indication of the efficacy of legal intervention in children’s digital lives. My presentation will, thus, walk the audience through my literature review, methodology, and aims for this thesis proposal.

Session 2: Digital Technology & Culture (2 presentations)

Hannah Vines, Maddie Cranston

11:20 A.M. - 12:00 P.M. 

3. The Digital Self: A Cultural Shift from Humanism to Posthumanism in the Internet Age – Hannah Vines

Generation Z (1997-2012) is the first generation to grow up never knowing a word without the internet. Introduced to digital technologies at a young age, this cohort continues to spend most of their time online and demonstrates a stark nihilism about the future (Twenge, 2017; Seland & Hyggen, 2021). Existing literature in the social sciences tends to explain these confluent factors as a product of sociopolitical stressors, individual pathologies, decline of third spaces, engineered addiction, and a technological determinism centered on smartphones and social media (Haidt, 2024; Jouhki et al., 2022; Kardefelt-Winther, 2014). While capturing important dimensions of this phenomenon, a crucial dimension has remained understudied; the narratives and symbols organizing and constituting Gen Z's lifeworld. As such, this paper offers an alternative interpretation, theorizing the digital turn as a cultural phenomenon. Drawing on the strong program in cultural sociology (Alexander, 2003), this paper argues that the turn to digital life and increasing hopelessness can also be understood through a shift in collective narratives about the human subject. By delineating the cultural dimension, my contributions are twofold: first, I challenge reductionist explanations that treat Gen Z’s predicament as a pre-determined consequence of techno-socio-political stressors or a product of individual pathology. Second, by emphasizing the role of collective myths, narratives, and symbols in shaping our self-interpretations, I advance the case for a nuanced sociological agency in Gen Z’s capacity to reflect on, and modify, their self-understandings. Gen Z’s narratives are demonstrated through discursive analysis of qualitative interviews with internet users in Sherry Turkle’s works published between 1995 and 2026. Within this data, users are found departing from the tradition of Humanism (Taylor, 1987; Calhoun, 2009) to increasingly draw from a Posthuman cultural framework that blurs the boundaries between human and technology and decentralizes the role of individual agency, deprivileging the human as a moral subject (Braidotti, 2013; Hayles, 2000; Wolfe, 2009). In turn, through a cultural sociological analysis, it suggests that prioritizing digital life over analog must be analyzed through important transformations in the cultural narratives that individuals use to make sense of themselves and what it means to be human.

4. Flourishing in the Time of Anxiety: Applying Practice Theory to Gen Z –  Maddie Cranston

Dominant narratives about “Gen Z” (born 1997-2012) depict an anxious and troubled generation. While accurate, these narratives raise the question: under which circumstances do Gen Z flourish, and what practices enable this flourishing? To study Gen Z's potential to thrive, my research develops the diagnostic and theoretical resources for a “sociology of flourishing.” This theoretical framework builds on virtue ethicist Alasdair MacIntyre's practice theory. He establishes eudaimonia, or flourishing, as the ultimate purpose of human life. Flourishing is primarily enabled through practices. Practices are complex, collective and virtue-building social activities. Painting, dancing, and friendship are examples of practices. Importantly, practices require support from their constitutive social ecosystems. An enabling institution, a connection to tradition, and a community of practitioners are preconditions for a thriving practice. The benefits of a sociology of flourishing are threefold. First, it offers a positive and social account of wellbeing. This addresses the limitations of individualistic, psychologically reductive, and ‘outcome’-based evaluations of flourishing that predominate research into Gen Z. Second, it provides a framework sensitive to pluralistic conceptions of flourishing. There are rational criteria to study flourishing (practices, virtues, tradition) but flourishing remains socially contingent. As a result, researchers cannot impose implicit conceptions or extrinsic psychological measures of wellbeing on research subjects. Instead, sociologists have an interpretive conceptual model to assess their participants’ wellbeing. Third, this framework reinforces social science’s normative obligation to study flourishing. Holding that humans are storytelling animals, it serves human flourishing to establish interpretively grounded narratives which advance our subjects' ability to seek their collective thriving. When scholars treat the good life as a serious object of study, they can demonstrate that flourishing is both possible and worth pursuing. In sum, a lack of insight into Gen Z’s substantive commitments and concerns about the good life hinders comprehensive evaluations of their well-being. A sociology of flourishing amends these limitations by supplying a theoretical framework based upon MacInytre's practice theory.

Session 3: Violence and Policy in Canada (2 presentations)

Kaitlyn Hunter, Maria Brisbane

12:10 P.M. - 12:50 P.M

5. The "Reach” of Legal Cynicism: Examining the Impact of American Police Violence on Police-Community Relationships in Canada – Kaitlyn Hunter

This project explores the ‘reach’ of public perceptions of police by investigating how police violence in America influences trust in and engagement with police in Canada. American-based research shows that high-profile police violence has a sustained impact on crime reporting in local neighbourhoods. However, sentiments from Canadian police suggest that images of policing in America travel beyond national borders, impacting police-community dynamics at home and raising important questions about whether these anecdotes reflect a material and/or symbolic loss of local trust and legitimacy in police. With a specific focus on civic engagement, this study tests whether the 2020 police murder of George Floyd in Minneapolis impacted police-community dynamics in a large and diverse Canadian municipality. The project analyses fluctuations in resident-initiated calls for police service before and after Floyd’s death, forecasting what cross-border call habits would have looked like in the absence of the Floyd incident. By comparing this ‘no-Floyd’ trend to actual call patterns post-incident, an interrupted-time series analysis reveals the causal impact of Floyd’s death in America on resident-initiated calls for police service in another geographic context. Subsequent interviews with 40-50 residents and 25-30 officers provide perceptual, dual-perspective insight into police-community relations post-Floyd. This study contributes to our understanding of how local police-community dynamics are vulnerable to exogenous shocks (i.e., external events that impact the institution). By providing a material measure and symbolic explanation of how distant policing influences local engagement with police, this project offers critical insight into the relationship between exogenous shocks, police legitimacy, and civic engagement.

6. An Organizational Analysis of School Violence Polices in Ontario Public Schools – Maria Brisbane

School violence is a growing concern in Ontario schools (Bennett, 2023; Cousineau et al., 2023).). While the most serious and violent incidents garner media attention (Amin & Bond, 2024; Bennett, 2023; Jackson, 2023), the daily experiences of educators are seldom explored (Bruckert et al., 2021; Santor et al., 2021; Wilson et al., 2011). Also left underexplored are the policies and procedures that govern incident reporting and violence prevention and intervention in public schools. Importantly, these issues can be examined using a macro-meso organizational lens to better understand the processes that contribute to challenges related to combatting violence in schools. Drawing on organizational theory concepts such as information silos and structural secrecy (Fox & Harding, 2005), I examine how school board policies and procedures may create gaps in knowledge transmission between staff and school board administrators. Specifically, I explored the types of reporting tools that exist, staff involvement, information sharing between staff, and variations across school boards in the province. To accomplish these tasks, I engaged in a content analysis of policies and procedures from 63 Ontario public school boards (English speaking) that were related to or directly referred to the Ministry of Education Program/Policy Memoranda 120 (Reporting Violent Incidents). My preliminary findings suggest that there are 1) variations in reporting standards across school boards; 2) limited language defining violence in policies; and 3) potential increased administrative burden due to the multiple reporting tools that exist at any given school board. Policy recommendations such as introducing streamlined reporting tools, improved definitions of violence, and introduce consistent monitoring and evaluation of incident reports will be discussed.

Session 4: Criminological Modeling and Policy Intervention (2 presentations)

Natanela Dain, Kay Katherine Adams

1:00 P.M. - 1:40 P.M.

7. Peer Language Use and Criminal Decision-Making: An Experimental Study Testing Framing Effects of Peer Messages – Natanela Dain

Introduction: Crime tends to occur in social contexts. While there is evidence that communication impacts offender decision-making, little is known about the mechanisms through which conversation affects an offender’s decision to commit crime. Drawing on rational choice theory, prospect theory, and need-to-belong theory, this study examines the role of communication, peer language use, and social belongingness needs on criminal choice. Based on the loss aversion principle, we hypothesized that loss-framed peer messages would increase willingness and perceived worth of offending more than gain-framed peer messages, and that fear of social exclusion mediates these effects. Methods: In an online randomized experiment, participants (n = 313) were randomly assigned to a gain-framed, loss-framed, or control condition, then read hypothetical vignettes describing two criminal opportunities: stealing and driving drunk. In the gain-framed condition, peer messages emphasized the potential for social inclusion if participants offended. Loss-framed peer messages emphasized the potential for exclusion if participants failed to offend. Those in the control condition did not receive peer prompts. After each vignette, participants rated their willingness to offend and perceived worth of the offence. Participants also reported measures of thwarted belongingness, situational emotions, and individual traits. Findings: Verbal peer pressure significantly increased the likelihood of stealing compared to the control condition. Although this increase was not larger for loss-framed messages, thwarted belongingness significantly predicted all offending outcomes. The effects of loss framing on stealing were significantly mediated by the fear of losing belonging, such that loss framing tended to increase the fear of losing belonging, which, in turn, increased the likelihood and the perceived value of stealing. These findings suggest that peer communication and need-to-belong play a significant role in shaping offending decisions and offer support for integrating social inclusion strategies into crime prevention and reduction efforts.

8. An Agent-Based Model of Illicit Street-Based Drug Use: Testing Intervention Strategies – Kay Katherine Adams

Creating effective illicit drug market interventions requires a nuanced understanding of how they operate, and even then, approaches can come with adverse social effects. Finding the intervention that suits a community can be complicated. Simulation can therefore be a valuable tool to understand social phenomena. Computational methods can generate sociological insights that can inform social justice policy in areas where traditional forms of data collection are impossible. This paper explores social service interventions, the current state of the local Kitchener-Waterloo drug market, and which initiatives are best suited to achieve a variety of favourable outcomes to support people who use drugs and are experiencing homelessness (PWUDREH) and reducing community affects. This study will utilize experimental modelling, called Agent Based Modelling, to recreate the current KW drug market based on interviews with local PWUDAEH and social services. We will then alter variables to observe the outcomes of various decriminalization, enforcement, and community initiatives. Enforcement initiatives tend to rely on large scale enforcement operations which conduct mass arrests and confiscation of drugs from users, dealers and traffickers, but can come with adverse social effects (Aitken et al., 2002; Caulkins 1993; Cooper et al., 2005; Coomber et al., 2016). Decriminalization focuses more on supporting PWUDAEH and reducing community impacts by removing criminal penalties for PWUDAEH, focusing on supportive intervention and diverting enforcement towards dealers (Hughes & Stevens, 2012; Smiley-McDonald et al., 2025). With the complexities of interventions, consequences of policy, social health concerns and the nature of socially stigmatized conditions, it is important to explore these issues and experiment to find the optimal intervention while also reducing real-world impacts. The approach of this study allows real data to be imported into a simulated environment to reasonably predict the outcomes of policy changes and provide a guide for new policy structures and intervention funding.

Lunch Break

1:45 P.M. - 2:20 P.M.

Session 5: The Politics of Meaning-Making: Qualitative Insights (3 presentations)

Bob Fantina, Alina Wei Yi Luo, Mrittika Dreesha

2:30 P.M. - 3:30 P.M.

9. Lived Experiences as Motivators for Social-Justice Action – Bob Fantina

Individuals become involved in social-justice movements for a wide variety of reasons. The focus of this study is individuals in southern Ontario who current act in solidarity with the people of Palestine. No definition of ‘act’, ‘acting for’ or ‘activism’ was presented; the recruiting process sought people who ‘act for’ Palestine, and that definition was left to the discretion of the potential participants: if someone self-identified as an ‘activist’ for Palestine, they were welcome to participate. The research explores the following question: ‘How do people in Southern Ontario interpret their lived experiences in ways that motivate them to act for Palestine during the current genocide?’ The research is a qualitative and purposive study, drawing participants from several Palestine-advocacy organizations. It explores the lived experiences of 23 people who are acting in solidary with the people of Palestine at this time. They range in age from 25 to 93 and include various genders (male, female, non-binary); members identifying as heterosexual or part of the 2SLGBTQIA+ population; people with high-school diplomas, Bachelors, Masters and PhD degrees; people who grew up in poverty and others whose backgrounds are solidly upper-middle class; participants with and without a religious background, and those who are active in a faith tradition today; people with long family histories in Canada, and others whose families immigrated later, among other differences. The research found similarities and profound differences, not only in the participants’ backgrounds, but also in how they interpreted their various experiences. This research contributes to social movement theory by demonstrating how personal biographies are translated to collective action through narrative framing and identity.

10. Claiming to be Hong Konger: Mainland Chinese Immigrants and Situational Belonging during Hong Kong’s 2019 Protests – Alina Wei Yi Luo

What does it mean to identify as a Hongkonger when one’s mainland origins remain a basis for exclusion? This presentation examines the experiences of four mainland Chinese immigrants born between 1998 and 2000 who migrated to Hong Kong as children and grew up in its post-handover education system. Their identities developed amid competing understandings of Hong Kong’s relationship with mainland China in the early 2000s, intensifying political conflict, and contested expectations of loyalty and belonging. Drawing on fieldwork and oral history interviews, I revisit the 2019 Anti-Extradition Law Amendment Bill (Anti-ELAB) movement through these immigrants’ firsthand experiences. I examine how participants understood and mobilized Hong Kong identity as they navigated protest participation, family relationships, and social exclusion. Their accounts reveal a double bind: identifying with Hong Kong and sympathizing with its protest movement could invite accusations of disloyalty within mainland family and social networks, while their mainland backgrounds continued to mark them as outsiders in Hong Kong. I argue that although the protests weakened participants’ identification with mainland China and encouraged them to identify as Hongkongers, this shift did not necessarily secure recognition or a stronger sense of belonging. Instead, Hong Kong identity emerged as a contingent and politically negotiated identification that expressed attachment and political alignment while also helping participants navigate the stigma surrounding their mainland origins. These experiences reveal the gap between claiming an identity and being accepted as belonging, complicating accounts that treat mainland Chinese and Hongkonger identities as mutually exclusive or assume that political participation guarantees inclusion.

11. Triangulating Work-Integrated Learning Theories: A Comparative Analysis of Human Capital, Credentialism, and Situated Learning – Mrittika Dreesha

Work-integrated learning (WIL) is widely promoted as a pathway to graduate employability, yet students’ lived experiences are often missing from the conversation. Based on interviews with 42 undergraduate Arts co-op students, this session examines WIL through three influential lenses: human capital, credentialism, and situated learning. We explore how students make sense of placement access, skill development, and the hiring signals that shape early career opportunities. Participants will hear what students describe as high-quality placements, including meaningful responsibility, dialogic feedback, and inclusion in core decision-making processes, and how these conditions influence academic and labour market outcomes. The session concludes with a practical framework for understanding how WIL can support access, build capability, and strengthen employability in ways that are effective and equitable.

Session 6: Gender and Sexual Violence (2 presentations)

Sammin Azam Suha, Anjali Kumar

3:40P.M. - 4:20 P.M

12. The Innocent, The Martyr, and The Temptress: Media Representations of Sexual Violence during the Anti-Rape Protests in Bangladesh – Saamin Azam Suha

As a response to rising statistics of sexual violence against women and children, oftentimes referred to as a ‘rape epidemic’ by scholars, Bangladesh has seen a series of nationwide anti-rape protests, most notably in 2020 and 2025. News media coverage and discussions on social media have heavily influenced the creation of such protests, but they have done little to reduce the occurrence of rape. Victims of sexual violence are also depicted differently in media coverage as rape myths and victim blaming is more prevalent for those from marginalised communities. This presentation reports on an ongoing study on how sexual violence against women and children in Bangladesh was represented in media during the anti-rape protests of 2020 and 2025. The study involves a comparative textual analysis to examine differences in depictions of child victims and adult victims, and of those from majority or minority populations. This presentation and project raises questions about the biases that exist in news media reporting, as well as its impact on sexual violence and sexual violence prevention.

13. Rape: Is it Rape? – Anjali Kumar

Despite assertions in support of democracy and women's rights, one of the most pressing issues in the Global South remains the non-criminalization of marital rape in India. India is one of the very few countries that does not recognize or believe marital rape is a crime. This research seeks to understand how the institution of marriage serves as a cover for sexual violence to persist in a marital relationship. Moreover, this research seeks to understand the intertwining of law, society, and politics in leading to the normalization of rape within marriage. I explore Section 375 of the Indian Penal Code, now changed to the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), that has an exception which states, "sexual intercourse by a man with his wife, the wife not being under fifteen years of age, is not rape". This wording creates a dilemma, where rape within marriage is considered not rape. There is extensive cultural, social, and political thinking that supports this exception, as rape within marriage is not possible because it is a sacred relationship. Marital rape, therefore, remains non-criminalized as hearings and petitions are still being heard in the high court on this.

Session 7: Governance and Gender (2 presentations)

Pinar Ensari, David O'Reilly

4:30 P.M. - 5:10 P.M

14. Gendered Gatekeepers from Below: Acts of Bordering Sovereignty in the Turkey-Georgia Borderland – Pinar Ensari

This paper examines how borderland men participate in border governance and sovereignty-making at the Sarp border gate on the Turkey–Georgia border. Drawing on six months of feminist ethnographic fieldwork conducted in Hopa, Artvin, between May and November 2023, I conceptualize borderland sovereignties as historically specific formations of power produced at the shifting intersections of state authority, neoliberal governmentality, and patriarchal relations. I develop acts of bordering sovereignty to describe the situated, ordinary, gendered, and intersectionally uneven practices through which actors without formal sovereign authority reproduce, appropriate, contest, and reconfigure how state sovereignty over border governance operates. The paper focuses on daçkacılar, porters from Sarp village who claim a territorially grounded exclusive right to carry travelers’ luggage across customs; tır sollatanlar, young intermediaries who manipulate truck queues and their sequencing; and customs brokers and border commissioners who facilitate cross-border circulation. These practices reveal border governance as a spatial, temporal, and gendered field. Residents convert territorial presence, procedural knowledge, social connections, and familiarity with customs rhythms into claims over who may profit from the border and how quickly goods move. Intensified digitization, surveillance, and regulation generate new practices of adaptation, circumvention, accommodation, and cross-border collaboration, producing masculine micro-sovereignties within, against, and alongside state infrastructures. These acts are pragmatic and inherently ambivalent, combining subversion, compliance, and instrumental engagement: borderlanders may challenge state power while working through its institutions, appropriate official rules and infrastructures for their own purposes, and assert local territorial rights to profit from the gate while collaborating across ethnic and national lines. In doing so, they may reproduce some formations of authority even as they redirect, unsettle, or place limits on others. Gender is co-constitutive of this process, shaping who can claim intermediary authority and convert border knowledge into livelihood and masculine recognition, while participation in sovereignty-making reshapes masculine hierarchies.

15. Bearded Beliefs: Norse Pagan Beard Accommodations and the Sincerity Test – David OReilly

A US military soldier in 2018 became the first member citing Norse Paganism, or Heathenry, to be exempt from a clean-shaven uniform policy. Adopted from a Canadian military policy the previous year, the exemption resulted in several high-profile news articles which now contribute to the continuing narrative that Heathen men must have a beard as a form of religious observance. Those citing Heathenry to wear a beard offer exemptions for Muslim, Sikh and Jewish men as evidence in their bid to claim a perceived advantage for themselves as a predominantly white religious minority group. Deemed a New Religious Movement (NRM), Heathenry has no central beliefs or doctrine, leaving practitioners to interpret the written records of pre-Christian Germanic practice for themselves. The referenced practices, mythology and history were passed down by oral tradition before being recorded in the 12th and 13th centuries. The most cited example by Heathen beard hopefuls is Njál’s Saga, an account of a man’s deeds between 960 and 1020, and the standards of honour and masculinity portrayed within. Contemporary men now point to an interpretation of the Viking Age that blends history and pop culture, creating a uniquely modern blend of the factual and fantastical. This case study provides insight into how understandings of history blur with a modern context, continuously shaping the past, present, and future.

Closing Remarks

5:20 P.M. - 5:30 P.M.