Notice of M.Arch. Thesis Defence Winter 2017

Scott Proudfoot

Of the thesis entitled: Reconstruction Site | Re-designing the disposable Expo

Abstract:

Building, supported by the practice of architecture, is churning resources into waste at an alarming rate. Our method of construction has its inevitable conclusion in a pile of rubble. Lamentably, the natural resources we build with are finite, and our exploitation of these has nearly reached its peak. As humanity strives for a renewable energy future, architecture must engage in the renewable use of materials.

In the long term future, architects need to design buildings so their materials can be recovered, refurbished and reused. Principles for designing in circular life cycles were laid out by McDonough and Braungart in their 2002 book, Cradle to Cradle.[1] In more than a decade since the book was published, there is little evidence that the process of architecture has changed to support design for disassembly and the reuse of materials. This thesis aims to outline a method of design for material reuse that supports a healthy circular flow of material life, death and rebirth.
         
World Expositions have become the epitome of disposable architecture, with renowned architects designing pavilions with an intended life span of six months. This thesis proposes a transformation of the Expo type from an endgame of waste to one of reuse. A contemplated Expo Toronto in 2025 provides the opportunity to reclaim a reputation for showcasing the future. The proposed brief for such an Expo challenges countries to exhibit stories of regeneration in an event built on the theme of reuse and recycling. The Expo is an ideal venue for the design of prototype pavilions assembled out of renewable and reusable materials. This thesis proposes two pavilion types, which at the Expo’s conclusion will be immediately reused in communities across Canada. The first type is designed to be entirely recycled when it is no longer needed. The second pavilion type is assembled of material which can be composted, returning nutrients to the soil. The resulting buildings will be adaptable to change, reusable in parts, and return their materials to circular flows at end of life.
 
[1]. William McDonough and Michael Braungart, Cradle to Cradle : Remaking the Way We Make Things (New York: North Point Press, 2002), 166.
 

The Examining Committee is as follows:
Supervisor: Terri Boake, University of Waterloo
Committee Member: Jane Hutton, University of Waterloo
Internal Reader: Val Rynnimeri, University of Waterloo
External Reader: Paul Dowsett, Sustainable TO

The committee has been approved as authorized by the Graduate Studies Committee.

The Defence Examination will take place:  

Thursday, January 5, 2017                              1:00PM                             ARC 2008

A copy of the thesis is available for perusal in ARC 2106A.
 

Back to defences

Snehanjali Sumanth

Of the thesis entitled: Submechanophilia

Abstract:

Twenty-three federal offshore oil platforms line the coast of Southern California for approximately 200 miles from Point Conepcion, Santa Barbara County to Huntington Beach, Oxford County. Installed from1968 to 1989, they are some of the oldest platforms in the world and currently face the process of complete decommissioning after having consumed the site’s 200-million-year-old reserves in just over a century. The site holds a heavy history with oil; from one of the world’s first offshore oil wells in 1896, to large and catastrophic oil spills, to present day, with unregulated offshore fracking.
 
However, beneath the surface of the water, their metal lattice structure that anchors them to the earth is covered in a thick layer of life, as they have grown into dense micro-habitats that support an entire food cycle - from deep sea invertebrates to fish and large mammals. The site composes the first half of the Southern California Bight, a zone on the coastal shelf that is rich in ecological diversity. Here, complex offshore winds and eddies twist larvae, nutrients, and plankton to the platforms, initiating the growth of life. The question of the preservation of life on the platforms has placed a doubt in the process of decommissioning, with many stakeholders speculating on keeping the platforms in place with a future use.
 
Inspired by contemporary French sociologist Bruno Latour’s spirit of inclusivity and collectivity amongst the sciences, this thesis proposes the reuse of oil platforms as cen­tres of scientific and field research, inviting the sciences to re-enter the site as a collective whose intention is to study and cohabitate with the site’s ecology. Gathering the sciences that maintain an interest in the site, the design aims to engage with site’s assembly of human and non-human forces and immerse into the forces of energy, matter and life.
 

The Examining Committee is as follows:
Supervisor: Adrian Blackwell, University of Waterloo
Committee Members: Anne Bordeleau, University of Waterloo
  Dereck Revington, University of Waterloo
External Reader: Joyce Hwang, University at Buffalo
 
The committee has been approved as authorized by the Graduate Studies Committee.

The Defence Examination will take place:  

Wednesday, January 11, 2017                          10:30AM                           ARC Loft

A copy of the thesis is available for perusal in ARC 2106A.
 

Back to defences

Marieh Dialameh 

Of the thesis entitled: PORTABLE POST-DISASTER HOME
Providing a long-term temporary solution for the displaced people affected by natural disasters


Abstract:

According to the United Nations statistics, since 2008, an average of 26.4 million people have been displaced per year because of natural disasters. In other words, one person loses his/her home every second. This is while these figures do not even include the number of people who have become homeless or are forced into living in terrible conditions because of wars and violence, or other issues such as financial difficulties. Sadly, the number of displaced people are increasing every year; this is while so many critical issues such as lack or shortage of proper housing or shelter, food, water, sanitary facilities and many other problems have still been left unresolved for those who have been displaced years ago. Because of the importance of the living environment on one’s mental and physical health, my thesis is focused on designing a mobile home that would be used as a long-term temporary solution primarily by the displaced people who have lost their home due to natural disasters. The proposed dwelling unit would be easily transportable and would include the basic sanitary facilities such as a toilet, wash basin, shower, and a mini kitchen, along with other spaces needed for a comfortable life. The tiny home would also be able to operate on the grid as well as off the grid for sites where no or little infrastructure is provided. The main goal of this thesis is to propose a light-weight, cost-effective and compact dwelling unit by exploring the concept of “expandability”, and to provide the displaced people with a safe, healthy, and comfortable living environment until their permanent houses are reconstructed.
 

The Examining Committee is as follows:
Co-Supervisors: John McMinn, University of Waterloo
  Rolf Seifert, University of Waterloo
Internal Reader: Val Rynnimeri, University of Waterloo
External Reader: Michel Caron, Caron Consulting Inc 


The committee has been approved as authorized by the Graduate Studies Committee.

The Defence Examination will take place:  

Wednesday, January 11, 2017                              2:30PM                            ARC 2003

A copy of the thesis is available for perusal in ARC 2106A.

Back to defences

Matthew Lawson

Of the thesis entitled: Collective Form: Infill housing and new domestic spaces in Toronto's residential neighbourhoods

Abstract:

Toronto is facing a housing crisis, the symptoms of which are apparent across the city; property values are increasing at a dizzying rate, rental vacancy rates are at historic lows, poverty and displacement are being made more visible by waves of gentrification. And yet, Toronto is undergoing a boom of residential construction, with high rise condominiums changing the fabric of large parts of the city. Housing in this climate is conceived as a speculative commodity, rather than as a space of dwelling; this is a crisis not only of affordability and access to housing, but also the quality of domestic space. This condition is not simply an issue of the current supply of housing, but inherent to its production and form. The thesis proposes an alternative to the contemporary production of housing, as a critical response to the housing crisis and contemporary domestic space.
 
The historical evolution of residential typologies in the city makes legible policy and planning tools as well as socio-economic tendencies. The initial subdivision of large scale properties in the early city into individual residential lots and accompanying commodification of property led to the large-scale production of semi and detached single family homes as the dominant historic type in the city, creating a perceived image of Toronto as a ‘City of Homes’ that persists into the present. Post war development expanded this production of single family homes to the suburbs, while displacing substantial urban communities through Urban Renewal schemes and the construction of high rise towers. While larger social and economic institutions have undergone rapid changes characterised by the current tendency towards neoliberalization, domestic space is still structured around the institution of the nuclear family, and the type of the single-family home. The thesis positions itself in the tradition of urban analysis and infill typologies proposed by architects like Diamond and Myers and George Baird, and associated reform planning movements that emerged in response to these patterns in the 1970’s, while imagining the possibilities of new domestic spaces that reflect contemporary living conditions.
 
Building upon this precedent of infill housing, the proposal contextualizes low-rise high density development within Toronto’s residential Neighbourhoods; large geographic areas of single family homes currently protected from any densification. The design proposal acts as a synthesis to these ideas about the form of contemporary domestic space and the contextual nature of infill, creating increased density for reasons of affordability for residents, but also to respond to both social and ecological sustainability made possible by increased density and more efficient land use. The logic of the building form is contextually responsive, establishing a series of setbacks based on the existing structure of the neighbourhoods, as well as manipulating the forms based on subtractive planes. A resident led development model is proposed to resist the commodification of housing, while creating spaces that are more suitable for a diverse range of contemporary domestic realities with reference both to international models, as well as a long history of cooperative housing in Toronto. The internal organization of the building reinforces these social organizational structures through the provision of common spaces and the collectivization of domestic labour. The replication of these typological experiments across the urban fabric allows us to envision the production of new forms of collective dwelling as a radical proposal for transforming the city and domestic space as a right to the city.
 

The Examining Committee is as follows:
Supervisor: Adrian Blackwell, University of Waterloo
Committee Members: Marie-Paule Macdonald, University of Waterloo
  John McMinn, University of Waterloo
External Reader: Mark Sterling, University of Toronto

 
The committee has been approved as authorized by the Graduate Studies Committee.

The Defence Examination will take place:  

Wednesday, January 11, 2017                          5:00PM                           ARC Loft

A copy of the thesis is available for perusal in ARC 2106A.

Back to defences

Sarah Gertler 

Of the thesis entitled: City Familiaris: A Study in Domesticating Infrastructures

Abstract:

Problems associated with hyper density in Canada are fairly new, but they often create innate conflicts for all those who dwell in the afflicted areas. CityPlace, in Toronto is one such place. The project is the largest master-planned community within Toronto and is also densest neighbourhood in the city. The model for its development is known as Vancouverism and the podium – tower is the essential building block of this style. The main goal of this type is livable high-density which is achieved through a created criteria and template for design. The resulting developments tend to meet the “requirements” needed and there are associated benefits, but due to their compliance a homogeny is created. This homogeny was passed down to the residents that inhabit these buildings. The great majority of residents are young, urban professionals. The problem created is that this particular group of people are also prone to bringing a being that was not considered in the design and does not fit within the homogeny created, the dog.
 
Dogs are abundant residents of these neighbourhoods and they easily show the problems associated with this type of development because their presence magnifies the inadequacy of the environment created. The neighbourhood lacks public spaces and accommodation; as a result it lacks community. This means that few feel the need to take responsibility for the neighbourhood and instead of understanding the problem, blame is often given to the dogs which are perceived as the problem. Considering this thesis’s estimated number of 2900 dogs within CityPlace and adjacent areas this problem is a very large one.
 
The intention of this thesis is to alter the flawed environment (CityPlace) by lifting away some of its deep-seated rigidity to make it more open to the other which in this case is the dog. When CityPlace was being designed there was no indication of the dog population that would reside there. No accommodation was planned for the disorder they may cause or the pressures that they would place on the finite, available green public space. This resulted in conflicts over the problems they caused. Since there was inadequate preparation, stop gap methods such as signage were implemented. As these failed tensions continued to rise and the presence of the dog and its associated by-products are now one of the most hotly contested issues within CityPlace and neighbourhoods like it.
 
The proposed thesis is designed to alleviate these problems through accommodation for the other. This lessens the rigidity imposed on the neighbourhood to make it more accepting to dogs and humans. This is achieved through integration into the existing neighbourhood that takes advantage of all the underused or under-planned territories. Accommodation does not impede upon the community, but instead makes it better. It also allows for the spreading out of design interventions which has the added benefit of diffusing the intensity of use. Not only will this reduce conflict, but it will allow for the design to become multipurpose. This will all be done in an effort to provide better accommodation for the dog while increasing benefits to all other parties involved.
 

The Examining Committee is as follows:
Co-Supervisors: Val Rynnimeri, University of Waterloo
  Mona El-Khafif, University of Waterloo
Committee Member: Adrian Blackwell, University of Waterloo
External Reader: Lisa Rapoport, PLANT Architect Inc.


The committee has been approved as authorized by the Graduate Studies Committee.

The Defence Examination will take place:  

Thursday, January 12, 2017                              2:00PM                            ARC 2003

A copy of the thesis is available for perusal in ARC 2106A.

Back to defences

Sheng Wu

Of the thesis entitled: Tactics to Tiny: Finding Your Way Home

Abstract:

This is a study of tiny homes and how they fit within the practical and theoretical framework of our regulatory housing system. It starts with a (much) smaller home but has social, political, financial and legal implications far greater than its physical size. Concluding with a guidebook of tactics in a choose-your-own-adventure format, readers navigate the current system and experience the choices and challenges it takes to obtain a tiny home. It offers conscious readers the opportunity to critique their own presumptions on traditional home-ownership. The format is congruent with the belief that there is more than one way to reach a destination and there is more than one destination when it comes to choosing our homes. We should nurture the small, agile, and convivial efforts of autonomous individuals making a home for themselves. The dweller gains back control of the home, allowing it to become one’s specific adaptation of the world.
 

The Examining Committee is as follows:
Supervisor: Val Rynnimeri, University of Waterloo
Committee Member: Andrew Levitt, University of Waterloo
Internal Reader: Donald McKay, University of Waterloo
External Reader: Fred Thompson 

 
The committee has been approved as authorized by the Graduate Studies Committee.

The Defence Examination will take place:  

Monday, January 16, 2017                          6:00PM                           Main Lecture Theatre (ARC 1001)

A copy of the thesis is available for perusal in ARC 2106A.

Back to defences

Dina Tranze-Drabinia

Of the thesis entitled: A Home for Urban Families: An Alternative Approach to Housing in Downtown Toronto

Abstract:

As prices of single family homes rapidly increase in Toronto, many families are faced with a challenging dilemma: move beyond the city’s peripheries to where house prices are lower, or remain within the city and attempt to find suitable housing in multi-unit buildings. Recently, more families have been choosing the latter, yet discovering that the city offers very few affordable housing options suitable for families with children. This thesis is an exploration into why this is the case and a proposition for a possible solution.

The exploration is broken down into two components: the political and economic framework of housing affordability and an urban and architectural analysis of design compatibility of housing for families with children. The findings suggest that a more comprehensive economic model is required, with consideration given to community land trusts and co-operative housing. Furthermore, a design approach which considers the amenities and diversity required by family life is seen to create a more inclusive built environment.

The research culminates in a design synthesis - a proposal of a co-operative building on an existing parking lot in Bloor West Village. The proposed design of the Home for Urban Families is exemplary in nature, in that it displays a possible solution within the established framework of the thesis.
 

The Examining Committee is as follows:
Supervisor: Val Rynnimeri, University of Waterloo
Committee Members: Andrew Levitt, University of Waterloo
  John McMinn, University of Waterloo
External Reader: Michael Hannay, W Architect, Inc. 

 
The committee has been approved as authorized by the Graduate Studies Committee.

The Defence Examination will take place:  

Tuesday, January 17, 2017                          3:00PM                           ARC 2008

A copy of the thesis is available for perusal in ARC 2106A.

Back to defences

Elie Bourget

Of the thesis entitled: The Small-er House Design Scheme 

Abstract:

There is a conflict taking place between regional and community interests. This tension is nothing new. Often times this conflict is borne out of urban renewal schemes and major infrastructure interventions in core neighbourhoods. As the ‘back to the city’ trend increases however, these conflicts are more and more likely to push into first-ring and postwar suburbs. With intensification policy, like with urban renewal schemes of old, it is the small things that get lost in the shuffle. In Ottawa, Canada, this conflict is being fought over character; sun, trees, parking, landscaping, setbacks, and affordability. These are not the most glamorous aspects of architectural design and many would argue change is inevitable. But if these characteristics were in fact founding tenets of a residential community, then policy makers ought make every effort to protect them as they set and pursue intensification targets.  

Unfortunately these low-density residential streets have fallen into a policy blind-spot and city planners are currently scrambling to refine new bylaws aimed at curbing invasive, or excessive, developments. So how do we add more people to these neighbourhoods without the wholesale replacement of the existing housing stock? For the suburb of Overbrook the answer may be to take a page out of the 50’s and go small, extra small. The introduction of coach houses would unlock a much needed source of infill for this neighbourhood, and many like it across the country. This thesis proposes their regulation and deployment aided by a federal initiative inspired by the postwar Small House Design scheme of the Central Mortgage and Housing Corporation.
 

The Examining Committee is as follows:
Supervisor: Donald McKay, University of Waterloo
Committee Member: Rick Haldenby, University of Waterloo
Internal Reader: Val Rynnimeri, University of Waterloo
External Reader: Michael Hannay, W Architect, Inc. 

 
The committee has been approved as authorized by the Graduate Studies Committee.

The Defence Examination will take place:  

Tuesday, January 17, 2017                          6:00PM                           ARC 2026

A copy of the thesis is available for perusal in ARC 2106A.

Back to defences

Sara Torki Baghbadorani

Of the thesis entitled: Contemplative Space: Design for Generative Parametric Tessellations Applied to a Shell Structure

Abstract:

This thesis focuses on a componential shell structure constructed through a generative, parametric, modular system at global and local scales. The shell form uses vault topology, is adaptive to various geographical regions, and serves as contemplative space. For this purpose, Grasshopper components hosting written C# code are used to design two strategies within a multi-layer system.

First, the design proposes a master system that is standard in both strategies, capable of expanding based on the region in which the design is to be realized. The second layer of this complex system uses the specific topology of the vault system. The two proposed strategies have the same components, column (the load-bearing module) and bridge (the module for covering the span), each of which exhibit different behaviours: first, symmetrical and homo­geneous form and, second, non-symmetrical and heterogeneous form. The internal decora­tion system proposed for each strategy is based on algorithmic geometry, with two different characters: the first is inspired by muqarnas as a specific vernacular ornament (primarily from traditional Persian architecture), whereas the second is a non-cultural, neutral ornament (originating from computational design and achieved by deformation of mesh division).

The research informing the design focuses on two main areas, historical and contemporary architecture. In the first area of research, two precedents, “Arabesque Wall,” by Benjamin Dillenburger and Michael Hansmeyer, and “La Voûte de LeFevre” by Brandon Clifford and Wes McGee are described. An analysis of these contemporary architectural precedents help to explore how emerging digital technologies, in collaboration with the past, can create a new design ecology and culture. The second area of research considers cultural and phenom­enological observations and the aesthetics of the design in its physical and psychological aspects in both historical and contemporary contexts, from the topology of the form to the visual perception of the internal surface that aims to create a “contemplative space.” This investigation indicates the points of contact between arabesque art as vernacular ornament and contemporary, computer-based art. Computational and parametric design is considered with regards to its effect on contemporary design culture. The parametric strategies, soft­ware, and C# coding used in the thesis are introduced along with Peter Fotiadis, the author of the C# programming. The spatial ornament known as muqarnas is analyzed as one example of algorithmic ornament, illustrated through a contemporary “art of the knot” designed using parametric tools. In the last part of the research, the features of the vault system are demon­strated historically and through individual examples of each kind. In parallel, the contempo­rary shell structure and methods form optimization by means of computational simulation and morphogenesis are investigated.

The parametric system developed in the thesis design, using C# coding integrated with Grasshopper software, provides an opportunity to design a complex geometrical system to be applied to the shell envelope. The resulting, stand-alone shell provides a shelter for protect­ing people from weather conditions, capable of hosting a variety of public or private activ­ities. The parametric shell structure is proposed to be implemented based on the decoration strategy, with the “Modular” strategy for specific regions familiar with the vernacular option such as Iran and Arab countries, and the “Vault” strategy, using a deformed mesh decoration, for two different sites in St. Petersburg, Russia and Las Vegas, USA.
 

The Examining Committee is as follows:
Supervisor: Philip Beesley, University of Waterloo
Committee Member: David Correa, University of Waterloo
Internal Reader: Val Rynnimeri, University of Waterloo
External Reader: Matthew Spremulli 

 
The committee has been approved as authorized by the Graduate Studies Committee.

The Defence Examination will take place:  

Thursday, January 26, 2017                          4:00PM                           ARC 2003

A copy of the thesis is available for perusal in ARC 2106A.

Back to defences

Shannon Wright

Of the thesis entitled: Claiming the Sky: Rethinking High-Rise Development in the City of Toronto

Abstract:

Toronto is following the footsteps of populated urban cities like New York through the extrusion of skyscrapers, transforming Toronto into one of the densest cities in North America. Rapid development of residential density has produced a mono-centric core in which density is favoured over sustainable social neighbourhoods. This “gold rush” of condominium development has superseded the production of public amenity infrastructure to support the density added. Limited vacant lands, coupled with rising housing prices and the ever-increasing population, points to a potential crisis in which the long-term sustainability of these towers is questioned. Towers within the core can no longer afford to maintain the existing inflexible mono-culture, but must include public amenity infrastructure which supports the rapid density and diverse populous. The presence of the “tower”, soaring far beyond the ground plain, has further amplified the social and physical disconnect of the cities fabric and its inhabitants, while removing the responsibility from developers taking advantage of the trends.

This thesis aims to investigate the production of tower “neighbourhoods” through the hybridization of vertical public and private spaces. The proposal aims to question the current high rise trends and limited public amenity infrastructure within the city and provide an alternative model for porous vertical neighbourhoods in which public amenity infrastructure is used to achieve social sustainability within Toronto’s core.

The Examining Committee is as follows:
Co-Supervisors: Rick Andrighetti, University of Waterloo
  Mona El Khafif, University of Virginia 
Committee Member: Val Rynnimeri, University of Waterloo
External Reader: Mark Sterling, University of Toronto

 
The committee has been approved as authorized by the Graduate Studies Committee.

The Defence Examination will take place:  

Wednesday, March 22, 2017                          10:00AM                           ARC 2003

A copy of the thesis is available for perusal in ARC 2106A.

Back to defences

Brock Benninger

Of the thesis entitled: THE OTHER PLACE | Building a Retreat of One’s Own

Abstract:

How is one to ground themselves in an increasingly virtual and abstract world?  The Other Place offers a complimentary environment to daily life. Here one can establish the necessary critical distance from the conditions which define day to day life, and gain the perspective required to position ones self within, or against, these conditions.  Interpretations of The Other Place, beginning with the ideology of Otium as expressed through the roman villa, continue today, varying widely across cultures, regions and individuals.  The Other Place, then, can be understood as representative of characteristics that are at once general, and quite specific, reflective of broad contextual considerations, and the particularities of its occupant.
 
The rich and complex process of designing and building a retreat of one’s own, in the tradition of the Ontario Cottage, on an island property 3 hours northeast of Toronto is used to engage with, in a rich and tangible way, the architecture, and understanding of the retreat as a complimentary environment necessary in contemporary life.  The act of building leads to an examination of how building and self are inseparable.  Building, then, becomes a means of architectural and self-understanding.  As The Other Place facilitates a wholeness in contemporary existence found through its experience, so too is a wholeness in architectural education gained in the pragmatic relationship between theory and practice found in moving from the studio to building site and applying knowledge gained from one to the other.
 

The Examining Committee is as follows:
Supervisor: Rick Andrighetti, University of Waterloo
Committee Members: Rick Haldenby, University of Waterloo 
  John McMinn, University of Waterloo 
External Reader: Paul Dowling

 
The committee has been approved as authorized by the Graduate Studies Committee.

The Defence Examination will take place:  

Friday, March 24, 2017                          1:30PM                           ARC 2026

A copy of the thesis is available for perusal in ARC 2106A.

Back to defences

Rachel Cohen-Murison

Of the thesis entitled: From Mountain to Maleh: Water as an Agent of Negotiation in the Kidron Valley / Wadi an-Nar 

Abstract:

In a site with significantly fractured political, social, and environmental governance, it comes as no surprise that the West Bank’s water network is fraught with issues. Over-pumping of groundwater, inadequate sewage treatment, and contamination of surface and groundwater are by-products of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The West Bank’s Mountain Aquifer system generates more than a third of Israel’s yearly water intake (600-700 million cubic metres) but is being heavily pumped,  supplying significantly more water to Israelis than Palestinians. A recharge area of 4700 square kilometres allows polluted wastewater from over two million Israeli and Palestinian inhabitants of the West Bank and Jerusalem area to enter groundwater.  Over time, levels of nitrate and micro-biological contaminants from inadequate sewage treatment, dumping, and agricultural runoff have increased, compromising future drinking water quality from springs and wells.
 
One valley in particular, Nahal Kidron/Wadi an-Nar, receives a significant amount of pollution. It is one of the only cross-border streams between Israel and the Palestinian West Bank to not have an environmental remediation plan in place. Framed within the parameters of the current Israeli-Palestinian conflict, research on the impact of unmitigated surface and groundwater pollution, as well as social inequity between communities in the Kidron/Wadi an-Nar, has inspired this thesis‘s design of architecture and landscape treatment stewarding environmental and social agency. 
 
The thesis first examines the existing context of the water network and political boundaries of the Kidron/Wadi an-Nar. Cultural history and urban theory inform the analysis of the site, further explaining how water and land are spatially negotiated and governed in a state of conflict. Finally, this thesis proposes architecture and landscape interventions at three locations along the Kidron/Wadi an-Nar. These installations operate at varying scales, from a small community park to large landscape installations, in order to serve as interfaces for independent water sourcing, distribution, and treatment outside of the existing de facto West Bank water infrastructure network. These installations do not propose a solution, however desperately needed, to the long-held conflict in the region, but instead set up a series of architecture and landscape interventions which shape how the sites would be managed in the future.
 
This thesis draws methodological inspiration from existing EcoPeace Ecoparks; design inspiration from the Arava Institute’s sewage disposal units for rural Palestinian towns, as well as from preventative planting; and an implementation structure from the existing Kidron Action Plan steering committee, as well as the Arava Institute's Centre for Transboundary Water Management. These groups and projects harness respective communities‘ agency over water within their broader watershed.

The Examining Committee is as follows:
Supervisor: Lola Sheppard, University of Waterloo
Committee Members: Rick Andrighetti, University of Waterloo 
  Suzy Harris-Brandts 
External Reader: Fadi Masoud, University of Toronto

 
The committee has been approved as authorized by the Graduate Studies Committee.

The Defence Examination will take place:  

Monday, April 10, 2017                          9:00AM                           ARC 2003

A copy of the thesis is available for perusal in ARC 2106A.

Back to defences

Rachel Fung

Of the thesis entitled: AquaCalifornia: Water Infrastructure in the Age of Scarcity

Abstract:

Water scarcity is one of the most prominent water issues worldwide. Globally, there are multiple countries suffering from various degrees of drought and the recent California drought is indisputably one of the most critical examples of the water shortage issue. A series of natural phenomenon triggered by climate change have caused depletion in the regional freshwater supply. This lack of freshwater has led to the closure of agribusinesses and decrease in employment and food supplies. Water shortage is not just an environmental crisis but also affects economic, political and social systems on multiple levels, and the golden state that once represented the American dream now suffers severely from its worst drought in 1200 years.
 
The situation in California is not merely a result of climate instability; out-dated water infrastructure systems and failure to capture potential water resources are also key contributors to the scarcity. Due to the state’s diverse microclimates, much of California currently depends on other parts of the region for imported water supply. Under the existing drought, the large-scale water allocation systems are proven to be unreliable as they further unbalance water stress at the source and end-use locations. Locally, there is also a lack of public interest and effective water infrastructures to facilitate the capture of stormwater and recycling of wastewater. Many parts of California fail to capitalize these potential water savings and simply direct them into disposal systems. This contamination and waste of runoff represented a valuable but missed opportunity to offset the drought impacts.
 
The goal of this thesis is to develop a series of decentralized water systems that focuses on capitalizing alternative, localized water resources in Californian cities, and could be simultaneously expanded as spaces for additional programs in urban areas. The speculative design would not only serve as a prototype for future urban developments and encourage planners and builders to rethink the urban fabric as part of the larger hydrological system. It helps reinvent water infrastructures to better facilitate urban life and actively engage the public in order to create a paradigm shift in the water consumption culture.
 
As dry conditions become the “new- normal” of the American West, designers must renegotiate the relationship between the urban fabric and its water infrastructure. Through the assessment and redesign of the current water network, AquaCalifornia proposes a new direction of water infrastructure development that helps construct a potent and reliable water future in California.    
 

The Examining Committee is as follows:
Supervisor: Lola Sheppard, University of Waterloo
Committee Members: Mona El-Khafif, University of Virginia 
  Ila Berman, University of Virginia  
External Reader: Fadi Masoud, University of Toronto

 
The committee has been approved as authorized by the Graduate Studies Committee.

The Defence Examination will take place:  

Monday, April 10, 2017                          11:00AM                           ARC 2026

A copy of the thesis is available for perusal in ARC 2106A.

Back to defences

Katherine Holbrook-Smith

Of the thesis entitled: Mediations of Shattered Water | Environmental Intimacy & the Dissolution of the Self

Abstract:

In a time of accelerated environmental degradation, a human-centric approach to engagement has engendered a pervasive cultural passivity towards the environment. This fatalistic detachment amplified by technological advances and, in Canada, the vastness of our landscape demands that we reanimate our perception of the natural world. Environmental intimacy aims to dissolve the “I-it” relationship through an affective merging of subject and object, recognizing that just as we move through the landscape, the landscape moves through us, resulting in heightened ecological attunement.

This research uses the sensing human body as the primary site of spatial perception. With a camera strapped to my body I encounter waterfalls. From these encounters, the sensations of shattered water are cultivated and reformed into cast plaster and concrete artifacts, deterritorializing the waterfalls from their physical location into affective material formations. These crafted artifacts are the distillation of my encounters with the shattering of water, extending the movement of the body through the landscape into the craft and navigation of architectural space.
 
The process of translation created to test the potential of affective deterritorialization involves the technical mediums of photography, digital editing, computer modelling, Computer Numerical Control (CNC) routing and vacuum forming to develop the sensuous cast surfaces. These processes bring the digital image back into the material world, resulting in a new form of cast landscape detached from a geographical location while resonant with the forces moving through it. These castings are deterritorialized landscapes of sensations which engage the integral and reciprocal relationships between the body and its environment.
 

The Examining Committee is as follows:
Supervisor: Dereck Revington, University of Waterloo
Committee Members: Anne Bordeleau, University of Waterloo 
  Jane Hutton, University of Waterloo
External Reader: Yvonne Lammerich

 
The committee has been approved as authorized by the Graduate Studies Committee.

The Defence Examination will take place:  

Wednesday, April 26, 2017                          10:00AM                           ARC Loft

A copy of the thesis is available for perusal in ARC 2106A.

Back to defences

Andrew Cole

Of the thesis entitled: The Reflexive Urban Fabric: The Re-imagining of Toronto’s Rail Corridor

Abstract:

The thesis The Reflexive Urban Fabric: The Re-imagining of Toronto’s Rail Corridor is concerned with architecture’s role in shaping infrastructural systems into designed composite networks that respond to local, social, and ecological conditions.

Infrastructural systems present a dichotomy between the technical and cultural influences that are inseparable from urban planning. They have been given technical priority over natural and urban landscapes for an agenda of higher mono-focused productivity, while also shaping urban fabrics in relation and interactions to the supplies with which infrastructural systems provide.

Through the acknowledgement of historical development within downtown Toronto, the infrastructural interventions of past eras have generated spatial conditions that currently constrict the desires of potential urban growth.  The city is forced to develop around these suppressing interventions, creating a tension between the growing demands of an amenity-filled contemporary city and the supply dominance of functional efficiency. 

The Toronto rail corridor is currently a void in the urban fabric, which is splitting the ground plane and limiting the connection between the city’s core and its waterfront. Thus, it is the exploration of reflexive infrastructural interventions along the rail corridor that attempts to reposition the role of the civic conduit and expand the perception of its performance to include social and cultural dimensions.

The primary intervention focuses on the Toronto rail corridor between Bathurst Street West to Blue Jay Way. The proposal is an investigation of the role of the specialized park as an act of reflexive infrastructure, where the layering of both social amenities and technical functions produce a composite network for Toronto. The site of the Toronto rail deck park is the first intervention in a larger series of interventions to re-imagine the rail corridor as a whole into a reflexive network of designed spaces.
 

The Examining Committee is as follows:
Supervisor: John McMinn, University of Waterloo
Committee Members: Rick Haldenby, University of Waterloo 
  Val Rynnimeri, University of Waterloo
External Reader: Mark Sterling, University of Toronto

 
The committee has been approved as authorized by the Graduate Studies Committee.

The Defence Examination will take place:  

Thursday, April 27, 2017                          4:00PM                           ARC Loft

A copy of the thesis is available for perusal in ARC 2106A.

Back to defences