Policy 71: Student Discipline
All members of the University who have reason to believe that an academic offence has occurred have the responsibility to promptly report the allegation to the Assistant Dean, Undergraduate Policy (Cynthia Richard). Instructors should contact science.integrity@uwaterloo.ca with the names of the student(s), ID#s, and the weight of the assessment. If a rapid informal process is possible, the instructor will get a response indicating they can proceed, and further guidance will be provided.
Science instructors are expected to be familiar with Policy #71 - Student Discipline as they are responsible for ensuring that academic integrity is supported in their courses. Consistent application of academic integrity guidance is essential to provide fair, accurate assessments of student learning.
Tips for Generative AI: Turnitin does include a detection tool for GenAI (ex. Chat GPT); use this with caution as there are reliability concerns. Policy 71 allegations need to be supported by more than just GenAI detection tool reports. Do not submit a student’s work to a GenAI detection tool without their permission.
Instructors could encounter academic offences, such as:
- Plagiarism; situations of limited paraphrasing but proper citations may be dealt with as poor writing. Use of GenAI also falls under the plagiarism category.
-
Unauthorized/excessive collaboration
-
Cheating; unauthorized aid; violation of test regulations
-
Misrepresentation, e.g., lying; falsifying VIFs or patient records
-
Impersonation, e.g., clicker misuse; distributing confidential academic material; forged signatures
-
Theft of intellectual property
Some Policy 71 Principles:
-
Students who receive an allegation are entitled to:
-
a presumption of innocence;
-
be made aware of the case against them;
-
have matters addressed fairly and expeditiously;
-
be accompanied by a support person to any meeting or hearing;
-
have matters heard by those who are not sitting in judgment of their own actions or decisions;
-
know, respond to, and seek clarification of evidence presented by witnesses; and
-
decisions based on the balance of probabilities with consideration given to University consistency and precedent;
-
Some reasons why instructors cannot independently assign a penalty:
-
Penalties are evaluated based on whether that student has had prior or similar academic offences; Instructors would not be aware of prior offences;
-
Penalties need to be consistently applied across the faculty and between faculties, and need to be aligned with Policy 71 guidance on penalties; Instructors would not be aware of typical penalties used across the faculty or university for a similar offence;
-
Penalties need to carefully weigh mitigating and aggravating factors in a consistent fashion, and;
-
The student may not be a Science student, in which case it would fall to the Associate Dean of the student’s faculty to determine the penalty.
The Office of Academic Integrity has an informative website containing general institutional views on the importance of academic integrity, and information on best practices useful to both students and instructor. Instructors are encouraged to review these resources to help provide academic integrity guidance to students through coursework and the course syllabus (see below).
Please send student academic integrity or misconduct questions to science.integrity@uwaterloo.ca. Aziza Chaudhry and Cynthia Richard manage this inbox.
Self-Declarations, Verification of Illness Forms (VIFs) and Extenuating Circumstances
Students have the following three options for declaring an absence. Students are expected to notify their instructor(s) before or within 24 hours of the missed course element.
-
Short-term Absence: students can self-declare, through Quest, an absence for 2 calendar days or less, during the Formal Lecture Period; a short-term absence can be self-declared for any reason that prevents a student from meeting their academic obligations, with the exception of Laboratory (LAB) and Clinic (CLN) courses/class components (LAB and CLN courses/class components do not qualify for accommodation as a result of a self-declared short-term absence); students are permitted only one self-declared short-term absence accommodation per academic term; no documentation is required.
-
Covid-19-related Absence: students can self-declare, through Quest, an absence for 10 days or less due to Covid-19 related illness (including vaccination side effects) or a requirement to self-isolate; participation in online course elements may be reasonable, and any participation needs to be consistent across all courses; students are permitted only one self-declared Covid-19 related absence accommodation per academic term; no documentation is required.
-
VIF Declaration: A VIF is a declaration of absence for students and requires that documentation be provided. Students must refer to their home Faculty's process for VIF submissions. Science VIF information can be found here. See also the Verification of Illness Form (VIF) from Health Services.
-
For extenuating circumstances that are not illness related, for which the VIF is not appropriate, other official documentation is necessary (for example: plane/train/bus tickets, court documents, police reports, death certificates/obituaries/letters from funeral directors, counsellor letters).
-
Science maintains a page with up-to-date guidelines for Accommodations for Illness or Extenuating Circumstances and can be reviewed as necessary.
-
Important Notes about VIFs:
VIFs (and self-declarations) are entered into a database (vif.uwaterloo.ca) to track suspicious and habitual use of VIFs. Unusual patterns of use trigger a meeting with the Associate Dean of Science (Teaching and Learning). Unauthorized use of VIFs may result in allegations of misrepresentation by the Associate Dean.
Student responsibilities:
-
Refer to their home Faculty's process for VIF submissions. Instructions for Science students are found at: https://uwaterloo.ca/science-undergraduate-office/accommodation-illness-or-extenuating-circumstances#submitting.
Instructor responsibilities:
-
Decide how to accommodate missed course elements.
-
Set accommodation policies in their course outlines so students know what types of accommodations, and under what general conditions accommodations may be applied.
-
Provide expectations: A ‘severe’ incapacitation indicates students are unable to attend class and engage in most academic studies during the period indicated. If they attend classes/labs, submit assignments/reports or write tests/exams during this period, they are at risk of being accused of ‘misrepresentation’; a Policy 71 academic offence.
-
In the absence of stated course rules in the course outline, students will be advised that they should consider not writing tests/exams during the incapacitation period
-
- If uncertain about handling a VIF, check with the Associate Dean (Teaching and Learning).
SUO responsibilities:
-
Verify VIFs are complete, with no clear indications of fraud. Any suspicious medical documentation should be brought to the attention of the Assistant Dean, Undergraduate Policy and the Academic Integrity Specialist.
-
Confirm information students submit with their documentation aligns with information presented in the documentation. This confirmation may cause delays in VIF submission completion.
-
Enter the record in vif.uwaterloo.ca. Information will be automatically emailed to not just the instructor of the missed course element but all the student’s instructors – to minimize the student inconsistently using the VIF (i.e., writing one test but not another during the same incapacitation period). Instructors will see what course(s) have been associated with the VIF.
-
Educate students about VIF use and responsibilities.
Accommodating religious observances
Academic Accommodations due to Creed/Religion
See UG Calendar guidelines on Academic Considerations and Accommodations
The University acknowledges that, due to the pluralistic nature of the University community, some students may seek academic accommodations on religious grounds.
Students can complete the Religious Observance Self-Declaration Form in Quest, which will inform their instructors of the potential conflict for certain dates. As the dates of important religious observances are generally known well in advance, students must consult with their instructor(s) within two weeks of the announcement of the due date or scheduled examination date for which academic accommodation is being sought.
The Office of Equity, Diversity, Inclusion & Anti-racism (EDI-R) website includes a chart listing religious and spiritual days of observance that instructors may choose to consider when establishing assignment deadlines and/or final examination and test dates.
Instructors are not obliged to make accommodations for events like religious weddings (although they can) because these religious ceremonies are not religious observances
Academic Accommodations due to Other Code Grounds
Students seeking an academic accommodation related to a protected ground (e.g., family status, and sex, including pregnancy and breastfeeding) should inform their instructor/academic unit as soon as they become aware of the need.
When considering accommodation requests, instructors should consider that:
-
Elective arrangements like travel are not grounds to miss course elements (see the same calendar section)
Managing Student Accommodations
Instructors can find a list of their students with accommodations by signing in with AccessAbility Services.
Emergencies: service disruptions, weather, and fire
For recommended actions to take when service disruptions interrupt the online learning environments used for required course activities visit: Service interruptions in the Online Learning Environment – Guidelines for Instructors.
Instructors, and their course proctors, should familiarize themselves with University storm closure and fire alarm evacuation procedures, particularly as they impact tests and exams:
There are no equivalent fire alarm procedures for in-term tests, but instructors are encouraged to adopt the principles of the final exam guidelines and ensure their proctors are familiar with these guidelines. Instructors need to consider whether the in-term test can be re-scheduled or whether the weight of the test should be shifted to another course element.