Critical thinking has always been crucial for independent thinking, problem solving, and research in students’ academic, professional, and personal lives. Given that artificial intelligence (AI) presents benefits and risks to students’ ability to develop critical thinking skills (Melisa et al., 2025), it is important to have strategies for teaching and assessing critical thinking with or without AI.
Many disciplines have specific pedagogy regarding critical thinking. This teaching tip, however, takes a discipline-agnostic approach to teaching and assessing critical thinking to provide you a starting point that you can apply and adapt to your own discipline and context.
What is critical thinking?
Critical thinking, defined as the ability to analyze, evaluate, and synthesize information to make reasoned decisions, is a fundamental cognitive skill essential for academic success, professional competence, and informed citizenship. It involves various cognitive processes, including problem-solving, decision-making, and reflective thinking, which are crucial for navigating complex and dynamic environments.
Critical thinking is a multifaceted skill set. Together with the above definition, it is helpful to consider Bloom’s taxonomy, due to its ubiquitous use in higher education course and assessment design. The critical thinking skill set roughly corresponds to the upper levels of Anderson and Krathwohl’s (2001) revision of Bloom’s cognitive domain hierarchy:
- Analyze – Differentiate, organize, attribute.
- Evaluate – Check, critique.
- Create – Hypothesize, design, construct. (p. 68)
Below are some suggestions for teaching and assessing critical thinking.
Teaching critical thinking through questioning
Critical thinking is driven by asking questions and using the answers to understand the world, including texts/media, other people, and oneself. You ask students questions to draw from them information, inferences, and predictions about a topic and the rationales for their responses. Questioning can be used in assessment prompts, class discussions, and oral exams, to name a few. Ensure you integrate questions strategically (read the Teaching Tip Questions Strategies) and model the type of response you expect. Questioning is beneficial because students will begin to generate critical questions independently if they receive models, structure, and guidance. Below are some examples of question stems (King, 1995, p. 14) that can aid students in developing critical thinking.
Generic question stems
- What are the strengths and weaknesses of …?
- What is the difference between … and …?
- Explain why / how …?
- What would happen if …?
- What is the nature of …?
- Why is … happening?
- What are the implications of …?
- How does … affect …?
- What does … mean?
- Why is … important?
- How are … and … similar/different?
- What is a counterargument for …?
- What is the best …and why?
- Compare … and … with regard to …?
- What do you think causes …? Why?
- Do you agree or disagree with this statement/answer? What evidence is there to support your answer?
Teaching critical thinking through writing
Writing takes students through the critical thinking process because writing requires students to focus and clarify their thoughts while putting them down on paper or in a document. Writing also requires students to make important choices about what they ultimately include in their writing. However, you should not assume that students automatically know what to ask themselves about their writing, whether in brainstorming, drafting, and/or revising stages. Below are some examples of questions (The Writing Place, n.d.), which can be used across multiple disciplines, that you can encourage students to reflect on regarding their writing to elicit critical thinking:
- What is my main point?
- What is my rationale for my coding decisions?
- Where do I make central points or questions clear to readers?
- How is each section/paragraph related to the central point?
- Will readers understand/believe my arguments, or do I need additional definitions, evidence, or reasoning?
- Where might the readers raise questions or challenges? Have I addressed them?
Some suggestions for critical thinking writing activities include:
- Give students raw data and ask them to formulate and write an argument or analysis based on the data.
- Have students explore and write about unfamiliar points of view or “What if [x] happened?” scenarios.
- Share a controversy in your field with students and then have them write an imaginary dialogue between scholars with different points of view.
- Develop a scenario that places students in a realistic situation relevant to your discipline where they must reach a decision to resolve a conflict. Have students describe the process they used to reach their decision and then analyze it: What could have gone better? What issues can they point out about their own process?
- Integrating AI: Have students summarize an important article in your field, and then have students ask AI (e.g., Copilot) to summarize the same article. Students can compare their summary with the AI summary and answer questions such as: Why did you choose to include the points you included? Why might the AI model have included similar or different points to yours? Which summary is more effective and why? Alternatives: Compare summaries generated by two different AI models; Compare two different reviews of the same book.
See the teaching tip Low-Stakes Writing Assignments for more ideas for critical thinking writing assignments.
Teaching critical thinking through group work
Group work is effective for promoting critical thinking because students are exposed to different perspectives while clarifying and sometimes explaining and/or justifying their own ideas. While an effective team has the potential to produce better results than an individual, students need to be prepared to work effectively as a team (see the teaching tip Implementing Group Work in the Classroom). Students may also need guidance to purposely engage their critical thinking and/or identify where critical thinking happened as a result of group work. Below are some sample questions to elicit critical thinking that you can encourage students to reflect on regarding group work.
Generic questions for reflecting on group work
- What concepts did I struggle to explain to my group members? Why?
- What is something that I learned from others and likely would not have learned had I engaged in this work individually?
- What was a point on which I disagreed? Why?
- If the group experienced conflict, why might the conflict have happened? What could have improved/mitigated the factors leading to the conflict?
- Why is [insert desirable group work skill] important?
- Integrating AI: If applicable, what were the pros and cons of including an AI chatbot as an additional group member? What prompts were used and how effective were the prompts?
See the teaching tip Group Work in the Classroom: Types of Small Groups for ideas for group work activities.
Assessing critical thinking skills
The activities shared in the first part of this teaching tip (inquiry, writing, and group work) can be used to assess whether students are reaching learning outcomes regarding critical thinking. For any activity, it’s important to be clear about where, how, and why critical thinking is being assessed. Here are two examples for papers and presentations, respectively:
- Paper (essay, report, etc.): Have students submit drafts to scaffold them toward a final version. Use the same rubric for each draft so students get used to the critical thinking criteria. Between drafts, ask students to explain why they made certain changes.
- Presentation: Have students use their judgment to prepare responses to your and classmates’ potential questions about their presentation, then have students respond to questions live. (Integrating AI: Students can use AI to generate potential questions about their presentations.) Ask them to write a short reflection about the questions they thought would be asked versus the ones that were actually asked: How much did inferring their classmates’ questions help them to prepare? This activity can either be formative or for low-stakes grades.
Examples of criteria for evaluating critical thinking
It is important to establish clear criteria for evaluating critical thinking. Instructors, and even students, might think critical thinking skills are self-evident, but providing explicitly stated grading criteria clarifies expectations and helps maintain fairness in grading.
The following are some characteristics of work that demonstrates effective critical thinking. You can use these criteria as a starting point for articulating discipline-specific aspects and grade ranges of critical thinking you want to assess in students. You might also wish to adapt an established rubric, like the Critical Thinking Grid (Word doc) from the Foundation for Critical Thinking.
- Accurately and thoroughly interprets evidence, statements, graphics, questions, literary elements, etc.
- Asks relevant questions.
- Analyses and evaluates key information and alternative points of view clearly and precisely.
- Fair-mindedly examines beliefs, assumptions, and opinions and weighs them against facts.
- Draws insightful, reasonable conclusions.
- Justifies inferences and opinions.
- Thoughtfully addresses and evaluates major alternative points of view.
- Thoroughly explains assumptions and reasons.
It is useful to assess students throughout a course, so you can see if criteria require further clarification, and students can test their understanding of the criteria and receive feedback. See the teaching tip Enabling Uptake of Instructor Feedback Through Feedback Literacy, which also supports students thinking critically about their own work.
Integrating AI: The criteria can also be helpful whenhaving students evaluate AI output, whether on its own merit or in comparison to their own work. These criteria might also be used to have students show their understanding of their AI-generated or AI-assisted work. For more assessment ideas, try Bloom’s stAIrcase. Click on a step and consider the activity ideas. For example, clicking “Judge” yields activity ideas for STEM, Humanities, and Arts disciplines.
Since critical thinking skills are multifaceted, designing and grading on a rubric can be helpful in establishing clear and fair grading criteria. See the teaching tips Rubrics and Responding to Writing Assignments: Managing the Paper Load for information on grading using rubrics.
Support
If you would like support applying these tips to your own teaching, CTE staff members are here to help. View the CTE Support page to find the most relevant staff member to contact.
Resources
- Paulson, E. (2024, December 3). Critical thinking with AI: 3 approaches. Faculty Learning Hub, Conestoga College.
- Roberto, M. (2024, December 19). Help students think critically in the age of AI: 3 ways to adjust your assignments to encourage deeper thought. Harvard Business Publishing Education.
- University of Saskatchewan Critical Thinking Tutorial
Teaching Tips
- Aligning Outcomes, Assessments, and Instruction
- Bloom’s Taxonomy Learning Activities and Assessments
- Critical Reflection
- Writing Intended Learning Outcomes
References
- Anderson, L. W., & Krathwohl, D. R. (2001). A Taxonomy for learning, teaching and assessing: A revision of Bloom’s Taxonomy of Educational Objectives. New York: Longman.
- Davies, M. (2019). New directions in the teaching of critical thinking. Change, September/October: 18-27.
- Gerlich, M. AI Tools in Society: Impacts on Cognitive Offloading and the Future of Critical Thinking. Societies 2025, 15, 6.
- King, A. (1995). Inquiring minds really do want to know: using questioning to teach critical thinking. Teaching of Psychology, 22(1): 13-17
- Melisa, R., Ashadi, A., Triastuti, A., Hidayati, S., Salido, A., Ero, P. E. L., Marlini, C., Zefrin., & Fuad, Z. A. (2025). Critical Thinking in the Age of AI: A Systematic Review of AI's Effects on Higher Education. Educational Process: International Journal, 14, e2025031.
- The Writing Place. (n.d.). Resources – Writing self‑assessment. Northwestern University.
This Creative Commons license lets others remix, tweak, and build upon our work non-commercially, as long as they credit us and indicate if changes were made. Use this citation format: Promoting and Assessing Critical Thinking. Centre for Teaching Excellence, University of Waterloo.