Poster version: Coaching leadership summary of results (PDF) - alternate accessible version below.
Association of Preferred and Perceived Coaching Leadership Behaviour Congruence with Playoff Attainment
Lee VanSchaik1, MA Candidate, A. Wade Wilson2, PhD Candidate, Luke R. Potwarka2, PhD
1University of Western Ontario
2Department of Recreation and Leisure Studies, University of Waterloo
Introduction
The purpose of this research was to explore the relationships between coaching leadership styles (i.e., behaviours) and team performance. Our paper was guided by the congruency hypothesis, which suggests that athletes ‘satisfaction and performance are optimized when there is a match between perceived and preferred leadership behaviours exhibited by a coach (Riemer & Chelladurai, 1998).Specifically, we expected differences to exist in the extent of congruence observed between preferred and perceived leadership behaviours between athletes who participated on teams that made the playoffs and those who participated on teams that did not make the playoffs. Our congruence hypothesis was examined using each dimension of Chelladurai and Sellah’s (1980) Leadership Scale for Sports (LSS). Specifically, dimensions of the LSS include: positive feedback, democratic behaviour, autocratic behaviour, social support, and training and instruction.
Methods
Participants were varsity athletes attending a large Canadian university in southern Ontario (n=61). The LSS perceived and preferred questionnaires were completed through an online survey engine. After the results were collected, a hybrid independent variable was created by subtracting perceived leadership behavior scores from preferred leadership behavior scores for each dimension of the LSS. These “discrepancy” scores were then associated with the team performance outcome variable (i.e., whether athletes participated or did not participate on playoff teams).
Results
Four initial descriptive findings emerged from our analysis. Athletes who participated on teams that did not make the playoffs desired more democratic coaching behaviour (t = -2.83; p<.01 believed="" their="" coach="" exhibited="" too="" much="" autocratic="" behaviour="" p="" desired="" more="" social="" support="" from="" and="" positive="" feedback="" than="" athletes="" who="" participated="" on="" teams="" that="" made="" the="" playoffs.="">
| LSS Dimension 1 | Team performance: Made playoffs | Team performance: Did not make playoffs | t | df |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Teaching/Instruction |
.36 (.57) |
.31 (.56) |
.30 | 52 |
| Democratic behaviour |
.39 (.70) |
.94 (.71) |
-2.83** | 53 |
| Autocratic behaviour |
-.23 (.66) |
-.69 (.94) |
2.11* | 53 |
| Social support |
.11 (.52) |
.55 (.50) |
-3.17** | 53 |
| Positive feedback |
.61 (.96) |
1.23 (1.04) |
-2.31* | 54 |
Discussion
Although our initial findings are descriptive in nature, they appear to suggest that this University’s varsity coaches may be able to improve their team’s performance by attempting to match their leadership behaviors to those desired by team members. We plan on further validating the results of our investigation by creating discrepancy scores using regression analysis techniques suggested by Riemer and Toon (2001). We feel our study may make an important contribution to the literature with respect to the use of our “playoff attainment” performance variable. Playoff attainment might be better suited than measures of wins/losses often employed in previous investigations. In the context of intercollegiate athletics, teams often make playoffs despite having losing records.
References
Chelladurai, P. (1984). Discrepancy between preferences and perceptions of leadership behavior and satisfaction of athletes in varying sports. Journal of Sport Psychology, 6, 27-41.
Chelladurai, P., & Saleh, S. D. (1980). Dimensions of leader behavior in sports: Development of a leadership scale. Journal of Sport Psychology, 2, 34-45.
Reimer, H. & Chelladurai, P. (1998). Development of the athlete satisfaction questionnaire, Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 20, 127-156.
Riemer H. & Toon, K. (2001). Leadership and satisfaction in tennis: Examination of congruence, gender and ability. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 72, 243-256.
Acknowledgements
The authors wish to thank the Campus Athletic Research Network for financially supporting this project. Additionally, the authors wish to acknowledge the contributions of Christine Stapleton (Associate Director of Athletics, University of Waterloo), Dr. Jim Weese (University of Western Ontario), and Dr. Katie Misener (University of Waterloo) for their help in conceptualising this study.